No, it's a very sensible interpretation of what we are actually told and using a shred of logic.
Unlike the entire theory of an Elder Dragon eating a God, which is a very inane interpretation and doesn't utiltise a shred of logic.
Mostly due to the fact if an Elder Dragon had eaten a God then there would be no more GW2 because that Elder Dragon would have won.
I'm honestly baffled as to where this line of thought has even come from.